A cookie scoop is an indispensable tool in every kitchen corner, and undoubtedly the best friend to those who frequently have to dispense cookie dough or ice creams. With such a deep and rounded scoop, it will no longer be an uphill struggle for you to do out uniform quantities without making your hands messy.
We bet that the wide range of cookie scoops on the market seems to make you overwhelmed sometimes. So how can you choose a cookie scoop suited to your cooking purposes? Our following article about the best cookie scoop American Test Kitchen will show you the answer!
What Is The Cookie Scoop?
A cookie scoop is a kitchen tool designed to help users disperse uniform portions of any food and even bake. Besides cookies, the scoop can be used for various foods, namely muffins, cupcakes, ice cream, or even smashed meat and beef.
Normally, the cookie scoop is made from high-quality stainless steel and comes in various sizes, suitable for different cooking purposes.
Best Cookie Scoop American Test Kitchen, Cooks Illustrated 2020
Here are top rated Cookie Scoop on the market today by Consumer reports
#1. OXO Good Grips Large Cookie Scoop – Best Cookie Scoop by ATK
- Product dimensions: 2.7” x 1.5” x 10.2”
- Item weight: 3.2 ounces
- Material: stainless steel
The first product on our list today is OXO Cookie Scoop, a simple and thoughtfully designed scoop. Available in three sizes: large, medium, and small, the OXO is perfectly suited to all cooks, as they can hold the scoop easily and conveniently.
What makes the OXO stand out from others is its strong and sturdy construction. Made from stainless steel, the scoop features a strong build quality, enabling users to scrape and swipe each portion without worrying about breakage.
Besides, if you are tired of cleaning after cooking, then you are lucky to have the OXO, as from now on, cleaning is a real breeze! It is dishwasher safe, allowing easy cleaning without damaging other kitchen tools.
However, one drawback of this product is its price. With such stunning features mentioned above, the OXO cookie scoop comes at a higher cost than the market standard. Despite the high price, the high-quality scoop is worth your money and will never let you down with its handiness and overwhelming cooking performances.
#2. Jenaluca Cookie Scoop Set: Stainless Steel, lce Cream – Best for quality
- Product dimensions: 11.49” x 11.02” x 1.81”
- Item weight: 1.46 pounds
- Material: stainless steel
If you are longing for a chef-quality kitchen tool, you must consider the Jenaluca Cookie Scoop set. Including three versatile sizes in one package: small, medium, and large, the Jenaluca enables users to disperse all kinds of food into uniform portions and bake them evenly. Ice cream, gelato, truffle, melon balls, and cupcakes are just a few to name.
Made from high-quality stainless steel, the Jenaluca is so lightweight and handy that you will have no struggle with holding and working with it! Due to the lightweight and well-designed construction, you are sure to experience each smooth glide and the ease with your wrist, inspiring you to cook and get baking.
Besides, for a left-handed cook, the Jenaluca is also an ideal choice, as either the lefty or the righty can make full use of this scoop with just a little pressure.
This quality material also eliminates any chances of rust or corrosion, which can blend into the food and make your dishes unhygienic and unhealthy. Therefore, you don’t have to worry about the health issues and food quality.
Another special feature of this scoop is its safe dishwasher characteristic. All you have to do is choose the right size, and then experience Jenaluca’s handiness and usefulness.
However, you might want to be careful when using it in cooking as it can be a bit hard to squeeze, and may pinch your fingers in the process
#3. Norpro Grip-EZ 2-Teaspoon Stainless Scoop
- Product dimensions: 7.75” x 2.5” x 0.75”
- Item weight: 5.6 ounces
- Material: stainless steel
If you cook frequently and always seek high-quality kitchen tools, then the Norpro brand should not be a strange name. since 1973, the Norpro brand has offered customers worldwide with the best kitchen products and high-quality services. The Norpro scoop is not an exception.
Featuring a high polished finish and made from stainless steel, the scoop is undeniably a reliable and quality product, allowing users to scoop various foods like cookie dough, meatballs, and fruit balls with ease
Moreover, the Norpro scoop is designed with soft grip handles on the two sides, protecting you from thumb agony, while the heavy-duty spring action can release food by sliding the band beneath it.
Nevertheless, although the construction is strong and sturdy thanks to the heavyweight and material, those two factors cause hand fatigue and can prevent you from working long hours with the scoop. Besides, the product is not dishwasher safe, as the metal shows sharp edges. Therefore, you should wash the scoop by hand.
#4. Zeroll Universal Standard EZ Disher Food Portion Control Scoop
- Product dimensions: 2.5” x 1.33” x 8.75”
- Item weight: 15.5 ounces
- Material: stainless steel for the scoop, and hard plastic for the handle
The Zeroll universal EZ Disher is sure to catch your eyes at first glance thanks to its modern and unique design. Unlike other cookie scoops made entirely of stainless steel, this product is designed with hard plastic gear, more lightweight, and reduced hand fatigue chances when used for a long period.
Plus, are you struggling with replacing the new springs after long-term use? The Zeroll will chase this headache away, as it is not designed with any spring! The scoop has one piece, ensuring an easy-to-use tool, especially suitable for both left and right use.
Overall, it’s hard to find a scoop that helps you make accurate portions like this Zeroll Scoop. Thanks to the color-coded handle, you can identify the right amount of any soft food like mashed potatoes or yogurt more quickly and easily.
However, as the scoop is not made entirely from stainless steel, its construction is not as strong and sturdy as other products. For this reason, be careful every time you work with it.
#5 Vollrath 1-5/8 oz Stainless Steel Disher
- Product dimensions: 9.2” x 3.3” x 1.9”
- Item weight: 5.6 ounces
- Material: stainless steel
The Vollrath Disher features a color-coded construction with a polypropylene handle and stainless steel parts. More importantly, the handle will come in handy when designed with a built-in stopper notch and has a ribbed surface. Thanks to this, there should be no worry about slippage during operation.
Besides, as the handle is a one-piece design and shows no notches, you can avoid the risk of water absorbance or bacteria invasion. Thanks to this feature, you can reduce the risk of unhygienic meals, or worse, food poisoning to zero.
In terms of capacity, the bowl is exactly 1-5/8 oz, allowing uniform and even portions of various food types. This size is especially suited to those who have small kids, as each portion is not too big or too small.
One drawback of this product is that it is only suitable for the righty and not designed for the lefty. Thus, if you are left-handed, we advise you to choose other products other than the Vollrath.
#6. Kitchenaid Gourmet Cookie Dough Scoop
If you are on a limited budget, yet desire to own a quality cookie scoop, then Kitchenaid Gourmet Cookie Dough Scoop is your ideal choice, as it comes at a relatively low price other scoops.
This 1.5 teaspoon scoop boasts a durable and strong construction thanks to high-quality stainless steel, promising long-term use, and soft grips on the two sides of the handle, providing users with comfort and durability.
In general, this well-designed cookie scoop allows you to make perfectly uniform portions, and inspires you to cook and bake everyday as it has made the task as effortless as it can get.
Also, the spring-loaded mechanism makes it so easy to squeeze the handle without the need for too much pressure. Overall, the scoop is dishwasher safe, a needed feature of any kitchen tool.
Still, you might want to keep an eye on the sliders as they tend to get stuck when you press the handle together. And this is definitely a pain as you will have to pry them opened over and over
Best Cookie Scoop Buying Guide
Here are some factors that you need to consider when shopping for a new scoop:
Cookie Scoop Size
Generally, cookie scoop comes in small, medium, and large sizes; therefore, firstly, let’s decide how big you want your meatballs, or cookies balls are.
A handy and fit handle is crucial, as it directly impacts your hands and cooking performances. The handle should be fit and comfortable to hand use. Padded and non-slip grips are recommended, as they ensure a safe cooking corner and relaxing experiences.
A cookie scoop is often made from stainless steel, as this material provides users with a strong construction and durability. Moreover, a scoop with a large spring would be better, minimizing the need for pressure to release your food from the scoop.
Ease of cleaning
If you want to keep your cookie scoop for long-term use, you should choose a one-piece or simply designed scoop, convenient for washing and storing. Moreover, the scoop should be dishwasher safe, as well.
How to Use a OXO Cookie Scoop (video)
Frequently Asked Questions
- What else can I use cookie scoops for?
Besides cookies, you can use scoops for any other soft food, including smashed meat, ice cream, muffins or vegetable mixture, fruit cupcakes. Besides, homemade crepes and pancakes are two ideal foods if you use cookie scoops.
- What is the best size cookie scoop?
Cookie scoop comes in three sizes: small, medium, and large; therefore, depending on your cooking preferences, you can choose your favorite one. However, we recommend you buy a set of cookie scoop, which includes all these sizes, so that you can use each scoop for different food.
- What is the best material for cookie scoops?
Stainless steel is the most suitable material for cookie scoops, as it is sturdy and strong. Besides, the scoops are free from rust or erosion with such a material, getting rid of the risk of negative health impacts or food poisoning.
The Final Thought
Cookie scoop is an ideal kitchen tool for tasty muffins, cupcakes, and water-mouthing ice creams, which are sure to satisfy your family members’ cooking appetite.
Finding a suitable cookie scoop is not challenging if you are provided with enough information and buying tips. And for this reason, we hope that our article of best cookie scoop ATK can be a big help when you plan to purchase a new tool.
Making every portion the same size will help your food bake more evenly and easily. So why not buy one cookie scoop and let yourself busy with appealing dishes?